Skip to content
Campus Alert Archive
The Citadel

Citadel Cadets Set Two Female Pioneers' Clothes on Fire With Nail Polish Remover: FBI Investigates as Possible Civil Rights Violation

SCassaulttimely warningmedium confidence
Confirmed Threat

In November 1996, junior cadets at The Citadel subjected two freshman female cadets -- Jeanie M. Mentavlos of Charlotte, NC, and Kim Messer of Clover, SC -- to sustained hazing that included spraying nail polish remover on their clothing and setting it alight. Neither woman was physically injured by the fire. The FBI and South Carolina Law Enforcement Division launched a civil-rights investigation in December 1996 after a male cadet disclosed the attacks to school officials. Mentavlos and Messer were two of the first women admitted to The Citadel after court-ordered gender integration in August 1996; both left the school in December without returning for the spring semester.

Alerts
2
Response
Killed
0
Injured
0
Institution
The Citadel, The Military College of South Carolina
Military · SC
~2,200 studentsCitadel Public Affairs / Corps Chain of Command
Confirmed Timeline

Alert Sequence

2 messages in sequence

Some alert texts below are approximate reconstructions from news coverage, not confirmed verbatim transcripts. Reconstructed texts are shown in italic with a dashed border. Verified verbatim texts have a solid border and are marked accordingly.

INITIAL ALERTUnknown
Approximate reconstruction425 chars
The Citadel has learned of alleged incidents involving the hazing and harassment of two female cadets. The school has requested a state law enforcement investigation and has restricted the members of the relevant company to campus until authorities can speak with all of them. Three student officers have been relieved of their duties pending the outcome of the investigation. The Citadel does not condone hazing in any form.

This text has been reconstructed from news coverage and may not reflect the exact original wording.

The school learned of the complaints on late Thursday December 12 or 13 from a male cadet, not from Mentavlos or Messer themselves, who had declined to report the incidents; the public statement was issued December 14
The company-wide campus restriction and relief of three student officers pending investigation was the immediate institutional response, communicated through the Corps chain of command rather than a modern mass-alert system
This incident predates modern campus emergency notification platforms; The Citadel communicated through public affairs, the cadet chain of command, and local media
FOLLOW-UPWebsite
Approximate reconstruction345 chars
The Citadel has completed its disciplinary proceedings. One cadet has been dismissed and nine others have received punishments including marching tours, campus restriction, demerits, and reduction of rank. These actions reflect our commitment to maintaining the honor and integrity expected of every member of the South Carolina Corps of Cadets.

This text has been reconstructed from news coverage and may not reflect the exact original wording.

The dismissal of one cadet -- the one identified as ordering the fire -- and sanctions for nine others was announced March 10, 1997; the harshest non-expulsion penalty was 120 marching tours with a rifle
The FBI and South Carolina Law Enforcement Division declined to file criminal charges, finding insufficient evidence for a federal civil rights prosecution despite the documented gender-based nature of the attacks
Context

Background

Jeanie Mentavlos and Kim Messer were two of the four women admitted to The Citadel in August 1996 following a federal court order that ended the institution's 153-year male-only admissions policy. The hazing they endured in November 1996 included being forced to stand on tiptoe in a doorless closet for more than two hours while being kicked and shoved, forced to drink alcohol and tea until ill, and subjected to fires set with nail polish remover on their clothing. Neither was physically injured by the fire. The attacks were not reported to school officials by the women themselves; a male cadet disclosed them in December 1996. The school learned of the complaint late Thursday December 12-13 and promptly requested a state investigation. The FBI opened a parallel civil rights investigation given the gender-based targeting of the institution's first female cadets. Cadet Jennifer Hemmer, one of the other two pioneer female cadets, had already left the school by November 1996; a fourth, Nancy Mace, was the only one of the four original women to graduate from The Citadel, doing so in 1999. Mentavlos and Messer withdrew in December 1996. Disciplinary outcomes in March 1997 -- one expulsion and nine lesser sanctions, with no criminal charges -- prompted broad criticism that the penalties were insufficient given the deliberate gender-based nature of the attacks. The case accelerated national attention to hazing reform at senior military colleges.
Analysis

Key Findings

Mentavlos and Messer were two of the first four women ever admitted to The Citadel, enrolled only four months before the hazing; the gender-based targeting was inseparable from the institution's contested integration process
The incidents were not reported by the victims themselves; a male cadet disclosed them, illustrating the acute reporting-barrier problem at institutions where hazing culture and loyalty norms discourage victims from coming forward
The FBI's civil rights investigation reflects the unique federal jurisdiction that attaches to hazing at institutions undergoing court-ordered gender integration; the federal angle is rarely present in civilian-campus hazing cases
The disciplinary outcome -- one expulsion, nine lesser sanctions, no criminal charges -- was widely criticized as inadequate for attacks involving fire and sustained physical abuse over multiple occasions
Nancy Mace, the only one of the four pioneer women to graduate from The Citadel (Class of 1999), went on to become a member of the U.S. House of Representatives, making the 1996 hazing crisis part of a longer public-life story
Outcome
No criminal charges filed. One cadet expelled; nine others received lesser sanctions including marching tours, campus restriction, and rank reduction. FBI investigation closed without prosecution. Both female cadets withdrew from the institution.
Provenance

Sources

  1. national media
  2. national media
  3. national media
  4. Source
  5. national media
  6. News
Tags
hazinggender-integrationcivil-rightsthe-citadelmilitarysouth-carolinafemale-cadetsfbi-investigationhistorical-1996corps-of-cadets
Added June 2026Updated June 2026Via ingestion